Sent: Monday, April 22, 2013 2:25 PM
Subject: Terror Tale
 
 Posts
Posts
 
 


2 comments:
Or perhaps the bombers will someday work as commentators for Fox News? Wouldn't be the first criminals and traitors to find gainful employment with that organization.
And if they had committed war crimes they would have be punished with a nice ranch in Texas and a sweet book deal.
Mr. Murtagh may have a legitmate complaint about the Weather Underground, since his home was actually attacked when he was a child.
However, Mr. Murtagh gins up a very stupid - esp for someone who is clearly intelligent & well-educated - straw man fallacy comparing the *alleged* (tsk tsk Attorney Murtagh) Boston Marathon bomber(s) to the Weather Underground.
I get it that Mr. Murtagh was very shaken & upset by what happened to him & family, but perhaps he should avail himself of PTSD therapy? I say that sincerely & genuinely bc otherwise, he seems to me to be rather obsessed on this topic and generally ranting about it in various way (do teh Googler & you'll see what I mean).
IMO, I certainly see no real comparison between the Boston Marathon bombing and the Weather Underground bombing of Mr. Murtagh's childhood home.
Murtagh's bellicosity and silly suggestions further weaken whatever potential good points he may have made in his article.
Finally, it's clear that Murtagh didn't bother to watch Redford's film The Company You Keep. That film was flawed but interesting. In no way, though, did present any sort of "justification" for what the Weather Underground may or may not have done. Rather, at least for me, it seemed more like a meditation, if you will, on some fictionalized (but based *loosely* on factual situations) events attributed to the Weather Underground... brought up to date with what some of those involved in the WU were doing today. It was interesting, but don't forget: it was fiction, not a documentary, nor an apologia for the Weather Underground.
Hence, I find Mr. Murtagh's screed rather tedious & pretty fact-free. Mr. Murtagh would do himself a real favor to get some decent therapy, so that he could actually *move on* with his life and find some peace and enjoyment. Ceaselessly diatribing about the Weather Underground is not serving him.
Post a Comment